Echoing the national energy debate, battlelines have been drawn between Victorian political parties ahead of the next election.
Echoing the national energy debate, battlelines have been drawn between Victorian political parties ahead of the next election. Image Credit: Yes 2 Renewables Melbourne (supplied).

Just a week into the 2017 parliamentary year and the Victorian opposition leader has made an error that could relegate the Liberals to the political wilderness for another term.

Victorian opposition leader Matthew Guy has kicked a hornet’s nest by going along with Turnbull’s ideological attacks on renewable energy—a universally popular technology.

The opposition has pledged to scrap the Andrews government’s popular Victorian Renewable Energy Target policy that will create 10,000 climate jobs, attract $2.5 billion investment to the state, and cut power sector emissions by 12 per cent.

Just how unpopular is the opposition’s pledge? Well, its anti-renewables stance saw over 70 people rally at electorate offices across Melbourne—an astounding effort after a mere 24 hours after the announcement.

One of the rallies took place in Caulfield outside the office of David Southwick, where community members called for the shadow minister for renewable energy to be retitled the minister against renewables.

There are two reasons why Matthew Guy has backed the wrong horse with his pledge to scrap the Victorian Renewable Energy Target (VRET):

1. Coal and gas

Road blocking renewables with a do nothing approach to energy will lead to increased power prices, lost job opportunities for regional Victoria and greater climate impacts.

The reality is that aging coal plants are closing and need to be replaced. The true cost of coal was recently revealed by French energy giant Engie confirming that rehabilitating the highly polluting Hazelwood coal station and mine site is estimated to cost nearly $1 billion and may rise.

Recent research by Dylan McConnell at Melbourne’s Climate and Energy College confirms that building “ultra-super-critical-coal” would be twice the cost of using renewable energy to meet Australia’s national climate goals.

Evidence also indicates that gas companies are gaming the market, controlling supply while sending gas offshore to maximise profits at the expense of consumers.

Wind and solar power are now cheaper to build than coal and gas, and the best way to put the brake on rising energy bills. Recent analysis by Bloomberg New Energy Finance found wind energy could be built at a cost of $80 per Megawatt-hour – compared with $143 per Megawatt-hour for new build coal, and $116 per Megawatt-hour for new build gas-fired generation.  They predict solar will become cheaper than coal and gas as soon as 2020.

Guy’s pledge to axe the VRET reveals an ideological opposition to the most economical new generation, wind and solar and pegs him to the most costly and polluting energy, coal and gas.

Taking a do-nothing approach to the energy system by opposing renewables is a sure fire way for Matthew Guy to make the Victorian Liberals the party for higher power prices.

2. The universal popularity of renewables

Manufacturers want it. And communities want it.

Just over a week ago, Friends of the Earth visited wind workers in Portland at Keppel Prince, Australia’s largest wind tower producer and a leading solar installer.

Keppel Prince General Manager Steve Garner expressed disappointment in Matthew Guy’s pledge to axe the VRET, asking “How much pain does a company like Keppel Prince have to go through?”

“Uncertainty around renewables leaves us wondering if business is worthwhile, if jobs are worthwhile’” said Garner. “How is the Matthew Guy opposition going to replace the 10,000 jobs that the Victorian Renewable Energy Target will create?”

The opposition’s pledge to axe the VRET is a slap in the face for communities who support renewables.

Barry Mann of the Macedon Ranges Sustainability Group (MRSG) attributes the Victorian Liberals loss of the seat of Macedon in 2014 to their restrictive anti-wind farm laws while in government.

“In 2008 we began working towards a community led wind farm project in the Macedon Ranges,” said Mr Mann.

“A deciding factor in the Liberals losing the seat of Macedon in the previous election was their policy to ban wind farms despite strong community support for the project.”

Matthew Guy appears to have forgotten the days of the trouble plagued Baillieu government, whose ideological opposition to renewable energy meant even community groups like MRSG couldn’t build their own renewable energy projects.

As Mann says, “Most Victorians get that climate change and cheaper renewable energy aren’t going away and any politician who doesn’t is destined for opposition.”

Evidence shows the majority of Victorians share Mann’s views. A 2016 ReachTEL poll commissioned by Friends of the Earth found that the vast bulk of Victorians want an urgent shift to 100% renewables, including a majority of Liberal voters.

As reported in the Guardian, more than 68 per cent of Victorians said they agreed or strongly agreed that “Victoria needs to transition its energy use from coal to 100 per cent renewables as a matter of urgency”, according to the ReachTEL poll of 1,137 people conducted on 4 August, 2016.

A majority – 51.2 per cent – of Liberal-voting or leaning Victorians agreed that the state needed to move urgently towards 100 per cent renewable energy.  Support was highest among undecided voters, with 70 per cent agreeing the state should urgently move to 100 per cent renewables.

Victorians love renewables and they deserve truth in advertising

This is why the Liberal party’s shadow minister for renewable energy David Southwick should be retitled the shadow minister against renewables. How can you claim to stand for renewable jobs and investment when your policy is to scrap the Victorian Renewable Energy Target?

If Matthew Guy fails to re-title Southwick’s position to reflect the party’s current position it will show that like Malcolm Turnbull he lacks the backbone to act in the public interest.

Without changing course, Guy risks a return to the troubled days of the failed Baillieu government.


  1. Most people are a tad more concerned with crime and the justice system imploding in this state. Yes liberal supporters may b like renewable energy but it doesnt mean they will support labor for it, its not THAT important to them.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here